|
The Art Law Group of Herrick, Feinstein LLP is sending
the attached press release on behalf of its client, the Estate of
Lea Bondi Jaray, announcing a major development in the long-standing
case of U.S. v. Portrait of Wally.
Press Release
The United States of America, the Estate of Lea Bondi
Jaray and the Leopold Museum Settle the Long-Standing Case Involving
“Portrait of Wally” by Egon Schiele
New York, NY (July 20, 2010) -- The Estate of Lea
Bondi Jaray (the “Estate”) announced today that the United States
Government, the Estate and the Leopold Museum Privat-Stiftung (the
“Leopold Museum”) have agreed to settle the long-pending case of
United States of America v. Portrait of Wally, which was about to go
to trial before Chief Judge Loretta Preska in federal court in
Manhattan on July 26, 2010.
The case involves Portrait of Wally, a painting by
Egon Schiele (the “Painting”), stolen from a Jewish art dealer and
collector by a Nazi agent in the late 1930’s in Vienna. The major
terms of the settlement agreement, which has been approved by Judge
Preska, are as follows:
(a) the Leopold Museum pays the Estate $19 Million;
(b) the Estate releases its claim to the Painting;
(c) the United States Government dismisses the civil
forfeiture action it brought against the Leopold Museum and releases
the Painting to the Leopold Museum;
(d) the Leopold Museum will permanently display
signage next to the Painting at the Leopold Museum, and at all
future displays of the Painting of any kind that the Leopold Museum
authorizes or allows anywhere in the world, that sets forth the true
provenance of the Painting, including Lea Bondi Jaray’s prior
ownership of the Painting and its theft from her by a Nazi agent
before she fled to London in 1939; and
(e) before it is transported to the Leopold Museum in
Vienna, the Painting will be publicly exhibited at the Museum of
Jewish Heritage -- A Living Memorial to the Holocaust, in New York,
beginning with a ceremony commemorating the legacy of Lea Bondi
Jaray and the successful resolution of the lawsuit.
The Painting was the personal property of Lea Bondi
Jaray, a Jewish art dealer in Vienna, who fled in 1939 to London,
where she died in 1969. The Painting became the subject of court
proceedings in New York City, after it was loaned in late 1997 and
early 1998 to the Museum of Modern Art in New York by the Leopold
Museum as part of an exhibition of Schieles from the Leopold
Museum’s collection. In 1998, Robert Morgenthau, Manhattan District
Attorney, subpeonaed the Painting in connection with his
investigation into whether the Painting was stolen property. After
the State Court of Appeals ruled in 1999 that such “seizure” of an
artwork loaned for exhibition was prohibited under New York State
law, the United States Government immediately commenced a civil
forfeiture action in New York, alleging that the Painting was stolen
from Lea Bondi Jaray during the Nazi era by a Nazi named Friedrich
Welz, and was imported into the United States in 1997 by the Leopold
Museum in violation of U.S. law. The Customs Service seized the
Painting in connection with that action. The Estate of Lea Bondi
Jaray asserted a claim to the Painting in the action, and the U.S.
agreed that upon forfeiture of the Painting, it would transfer to
the Estate all right and title to the Painting.
Based on the evidence presented during the case, Judge
Preska ruled last fall that the Painting was the personal property
of Lea Bondi Jaray and that it was stolen from her in Vienna in the
late 1930's by Friedrich Welz, who was a member and collaborator of
the Nazi party. The Court found that the Painting had been seized
from Welz by U.S. Forces in Austria after World War II and delivered
in 1947 to the Austrian Federal Office for the Preservation of
Historical Monuments (the “Bundesdenkmalamt”), along with paintings
Welz had acquired from Dr. Heinrich Rieger, a Jewish art collector
who had perished during the Holocaust. In 1950, the Bundesdenkmalamt
delivered artworks to an agent for the Rieger heirs and included the
Painting in the delivery. Later that year, the Rieger heirs sold
their works to the Austrian National Gallery (the “Belvedere”), and
the Painting was included in the delivery of the artworks to the
Belvedere. In 1954, the Belvedere traded the Painting to Dr. Rudolf
Leopold. In 1994, Dr. Leopold transferred the Painting to the
Leopold Museum.
In a statement, representatives of the Estate
expressed their appreciation at reaching this historic settlement,
which reflects the true value of the Painting, and acknowledges Lea
Bondi Jaray’s ownership of the Painting and her and her family’s
long quest for justice. In addition, they underscored that the
public display of the Painting at the Museum of Jewish Heritage in
New York will mean that visitors will be able to view the Painting
in a setting that memorializes the sufferings of so many in the
Holocaust and the resilience and resolve of those who escaped and/or
survived. They added that the permanent signage reflecting the
Painting’s true provenance will ensure that future generations are
told the real story of the Painting’s theft from Lea Bondi Jaray
during the Nazi era.
In conclusion, the Estate representatives said:
“Justice has been served. Finally, after more than 70 years, the
wrongs suffered by Lea Bondi Jaray are at last being acknowledged
and, to some degree, corrected. We are grateful to the many people
who helped Lea and her family during these many years. We especially
thank our attorneys at Herrick, Feinstein, and all the members of
the Asset Forfeiture Unit team of the U.S. Attorney’s Office, led by
Assistant U.S. Attorney Sharon Cohen Levin, for their unstinting
dedication to the pursuit of justice during the long course of this
litigation.”
| For further information, contact: |
|
| Attorneys for the Estate of Lea Bondi
Jaray: |
Herrick, Feinstein LLP |
| |
Howard N. Spiegler, Esq. |
| |
Lawrence M. Kaye,
Esq. |
| |
Mari-Claudia Jiménez, Esq. |
| |
Tel: 212-592-1444 |
| |
Email: hspiegler@herrick.com | |